November 18: Why People Don’t Always Speak Up



Why People Don't Always Speak Up

Most workplaces have a bullying and harassment policy tucked away somewhere, usually alongside a reassuring statement about treating everyone with dignity and respect. There might be a reporting procedure, a named person to contact and a commitment to taking concerns seriously. On paper, it can all look rather encouraging. But having a policy that tells people they can speak up and creating an environment where they genuinely feel safe doing so are two very different things, particularly when raising a concern could affect their relationships, reputation or future opportunities.

As we continue Anti-Bullying Week and our November Breaking the Silence series, we're exploring why people don't always report bullying, even when they recognise that what's happening to them is unacceptable. It's easy to assume that someone experiencing harmful behaviour would naturally want to tell somebody, but the decision to speak up can involve weighing up consequences that aren't always visible to the people around them. And when those consequences feel significant, remaining silent can sometimes seem like the only way to protect themselves.

One of the biggest concerns is retaliation, particularly when the person responsible for the behaviour has influence over somebody's working life. An employee might worry that raising a complaint about their manager could affect their performance reviews, opportunities for promotion or relationships with colleagues. Even when an organisation has policies designed to prevent victimisation, people may still fear more subtle consequences, such as being excluded from projects, treated differently or developing a reputation for being difficult. These concerns can be particularly significant when somebody relies on their employment for financial security or feels they have limited opportunities to move elsewhere.

There is also the question of whether somebody believes they'll be taken seriously. Perhaps they've previously raised a smaller concern and been told they misunderstood the situation, or they've watched another colleague speak up only for the behaviour to be dismissed as a personality clash. Sometimes the person responsible for bullying is well liked, professionally successful or considered indispensable to the organisation, making it difficult for others to imagine their behaviour being challenged. When someone sees that popularity or performance appears to carry more weight than respectful behaviour, it can influence whether they believe reporting their own experiences will achieve anything.

Power imbalances can make these situations particularly complicated. We often associate power with seniority, but it can also come from social influence, professional relationships, access to opportunities or simply being part of an established group. Somebody who is new to an organisation, working on a temporary contract or already feeling excluded may be especially conscious of the risks involved in challenging somebody with greater influence. And when the person experiencing bullying is also navigating discrimination or other barriers to inclusion, those concerns can become even more difficult to manage.

Another challenge is that bullying isn't always easy to explain. As we've explored earlier this week, repeated exclusion, undermining and subtle intimidation can be difficult to describe when individual incidents appear relatively minor. Someone may spend considerable time questioning whether they're overreacting, trying to remember specific examples or worrying that their concerns won't seem serious enough when explained to somebody else. The emotional effort involved in documenting experiences, preparing for difficult conversations and potentially having those experiences challenged can be exhausting, particularly when the behaviour has already affected their confidence and wellbeing.

And this is where the responsibility placed on people experiencing bullying deserves closer attention. We regularly encourage individuals to be confident, establish boundaries and report unacceptable behaviour, all of which can be valuable. But sometimes those messages unintentionally suggest that resolving bullying depends primarily on the person being targeted finding the courage to challenge it. In reality, someone shouldn't have to become an expert in workplace policies, gather an overwhelming amount of evidence or risk their professional future simply to be treated with dignity.

Organisations have a responsibility to ensure that reporting concerns doesn't become another difficult experience for the person already affected. That means providing clear and accessible routes for raising concerns, responding promptly and fairly, protecting confidentiality as far as possible and taking appropriate steps to prevent retaliation. It also means recognising that people may need different forms of support and that not everyone will feel comfortable approaching their direct manager, particularly if that manager is involved in the situation.

Importantly, taking concerns seriously doesn't mean automatically assuming that every allegation has been established. Fair processes matter for everyone involved, and organisations need to examine concerns carefully, listen to relevant perspectives and respond proportionately to the evidence. But fairness should never become an excuse for dismissing somebody's experience before it has been properly considered, just as the absence of an immediate formal complaint shouldn't be interpreted as proof that nothing is wrong.

There is also a wider cultural responsibility that extends beyond HR teams and formal reporting procedures. Leaders who consistently challenge disrespectful behaviour, managers who respond constructively to concerns and colleagues who refuse to normalise humiliation or exclusion can all contribute to environments where bullying is less likely to become established. When employees see that expectations apply equally to everyone, including senior leaders and high performers, they have greater reason to trust that concerns will be handled appropriately.

At Powered by Diversity, we often explore how psychological safety, inclusive leadership and accountability influence workplace culture. Creating an environment where people feel comfortable raising concerns involves more than encouraging open communication. It requires organisations to demonstrate, through their everyday decisions and responses, that employees will be listened to respectfully and that speaking up won't automatically place their relationships or opportunities at risk. Trust is built through consistent behaviour, particularly when organisations are faced with situations that are uncomfortable or difficult to address.

There is something encouraging about recognising that these barriers aren't inevitable. Organisations can review whether their reporting processes are genuinely accessible, consider how employees experience those procedures and ensure managers understand their responsibilities when concerns are raised. They can also pay attention to patterns of behaviour before somebody feels they have no option but to make a formal complaint, creating opportunities to address problems earlier and prevent further harm.

As we continue Breaking the Silence, it's worth remembering that speaking up about bullying can require considerably more than confidence. It can involve navigating uncertainty, protecting important relationships and trusting that the people responsible for addressing the situation will respond appropriately. Rather than judging somebody for hesitating to report their experiences, we should be asking whether the systems and cultures around them have given them good reason to feel safe.

Not yet a member of Cultural Calendar Club? Join today or Contact Us

Next
Next

November 17: The Bullying We Don’t Always Recognise