November 16: It’s Only Banter Until It Isn’t



It's Only Banter Until It Isn't

We all know someone who loves a bit of banter. The person who has a witty comeback for everything, can turn the most ordinary situation into a running joke and somehow manages to find humour in even the dullest Monday morning meeting. And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. Humour is one of the loveliest parts of human connection, helping us build friendships, navigate awkward moments and occasionally survive a working week that feels approximately three months long. But there's a difference between laughing with somebody and making somebody the reason everyone else is laughing.

Today marks the beginning of Anti-Bullying Week, and as we continue our November Breaking the Silence series, we're exploring the moment when humour stops feeling funny and starts becoming harmful. Bullying doesn't always involve obvious confrontation or aggression. Sometimes it arrives wrapped in a joke, followed by the familiar reassurance that somebody was “only having a laugh”. Banter can be a wonderful part of friendships and workplace relationships when everyone involved feels comfortable, included and able to respond in the same spirit. The problem arises when the laughter becomes one-sided, when the same person is repeatedly singled out or when somebody feels they have to join in with jokes at their own expense to avoid appearing oversensitive.

One of the challenges with humour is that we often judge it by the intention of the person making the joke rather than the experience of the person receiving it. Somebody might genuinely believe they're being funny and have no desire to cause harm, but good intentions don't automatically prevent hurt. If a colleague repeatedly makes jokes about somebody's appearance, accent, abilities or personal circumstances, the fact that they intended to entertain doesn't erase the embarrassment those comments may create. Equally, not every joke that lands badly is bullying, and people should have opportunities to recognise when they've caused offence, apologise and learn. What matters is how we respond when somebody tells us that a boundary has been crossed, particularly when the behaviour has become a repeated pattern.

There is something particularly uncomfortable about the expectation that people should laugh along when they're the subject of a joke. Many of us have probably smiled at something that didn't feel especially funny, simply because challenging it would have made the situation awkward. For somebody who is regularly targeted, that pressure can become much more significant. They may worry about being labelled humourless, damaging friendships or making themselves an even greater target, especially when the person making the jokes is popular or influential within the group. Laughing along can become a way of navigating an uncomfortable situation rather than evidence that somebody is genuinely enjoying it.

This is where power and belonging become important. In a workplace, a senior colleague who regularly makes jokes at somebody's expense may not recognise how difficult it feels for that person to challenge them. Within a school, a child may tolerate humiliating comments because the alternative could mean losing friendships or becoming socially isolated. Even within established friendship groups, somebody who has become the regular target of jokes may feel that speaking up would change their place within the group. The ability to say “that's not funny” without fearing the consequences is an important part of healthy relationships, and it isn't always shared equally.

Humour can also reinforce stereotypes and inequalities, particularly when jokes rely on somebody's gender, race, disability, sexuality, religion or other aspects of their identity. Comments that are dismissed as harmless may contribute to environments where certain people are repeatedly made to feel different or less valued. This doesn't mean that every conversation needs to become a careful exercise in avoiding offence, but it does mean recognising that humour doesn't exist separately from the attitudes and assumptions we bring into our relationships.

Perhaps one of the most revealing moments is what happens when somebody says they've had enough. In a healthy relationship, that might lead to an apology, a little reflection and a change in behaviour. But in environments where bullying has become normalised, the person raising the concern may instead be accused of being too sensitive or unable to take a joke. Suddenly, the conversation becomes about their reaction rather than the behaviour that caused it, and the person who has been made uncomfortable is expected to manage everybody else's feelings about being challenged. Phrases such as “it's just banter” or “you know what they're like” can minimise experiences that deserve to be taken seriously, particularly when they're used to excuse behaviour somebody has already asked to stop.

There is also an important role for the people who witness these interactions. When a joke makes somebody visibly uncomfortable, it can be tempting to stay quiet, especially if challenging the person responsible might create tension. But we don't always need a dramatic confrontation to make a difference. Sometimes changing the subject, checking in privately or refusing to join in with repeated jokes at somebody's expense can help shift the atmosphere. Where behaviour becomes persistent or serious, it may also be important to raise concerns through appropriate channels rather than leaving the person affected to manage the situation alone.

Within workplaces, leaders have a particular responsibility to recognise when humour is being used to undermine people. A team might describe itself as having a brilliant sense of humour, but if certain employees regularly feel embarrassed, excluded or unable to challenge comments, that culture may not be as inclusive as it appears. At Powered by Diversity, we often explore how everyday behaviours influence workplace culture and people's sense of belonging. Creating inclusive environments doesn't mean removing humour or expecting everybody to communicate in exactly the same way. It means encouraging the awareness, empathy and accountability that allow people to enjoy themselves without making others feel uncomfortable or excluded.

As Anti-Bullying Week begins, it's worth remembering that tackling bullying isn't simply about identifying the most obvious examples of harmful behaviour. It's also about recognising the smaller interactions that can gradually become accepted within a group, particularly when nobody feels comfortable questioning them.

Not yet a member of Cultural Calendar Club? Join today or Contact Us

Next
Next

November 15: Staying Silent